Musings on deep instruments
In short
When can a didgeridoo really be called a deep instrument? From my experience with instruments up to 7 metres long:
- Three categories: common (G 97.9 – B 61.7 Hz), middle (A 55 – E 41.2 Hz) and deep (D 36.7 Hz or lower, at least 4 metres).
- It is not worth going below A 27.5 Hz (G 24.5 Hz at most); beyond 6.5 metres the sound becomes artificial.
- Middle instruments are the most demanding to play, but the ones that offer the most possibilities.
In this article (9 sections)
- The old dogma
- Common, middle and deep
- What is the lowest note of a deep instrument?
- Is there a maximum length for a deep instrument?
- Lips, cheeks and diaphragm: what are the differences?
- Which category offers the most possibilities?
- Is playing deep a fad?
- Why start playing middles and deeps?
- The notes mentioned in this article
Premise: this piece is based on my practical experience and on informal discussions with other musicians, without studies or measurements with electronic equipment. Consider it a first-hand account, not an academic text: I believe it will be useful at least to beginners, both those who play the didgeridoo and those who want to start playing instruments of unusual key and length. I know well that experienced players and makers will find several inaccuracies and topics that would have deserved deeper treatment.
Notes are given with their English names; at the end of the article you will find a table with all the notes mentioned, their octave and their frequencies.
The old dogma
Back in the very distant (for the didgeridoo world) 2006/2007, very skilled and established names on the scene often said that, to create complex phrasing and/or play fast, a didgeridoo should not be pitched lower than D 73.4 Hz. Instruments in C 65.4 Hz or B 61.7 Hz were considered suitable only for meditative pieces or rhythmless “sound carpets”. An instrument in A 55 Hz was at the limit of playability, and a 2-metre didgeridoo looked like a freak of nature!
Then two great European players came along: first Ondřej Smeykal and then Dubravko Lapaine (it was mainly thanks to the latter that the dogma was revised). Both showed that complex patterns and/or fast playing were possible on instruments longer than 2 metres and/or pitched at C 65.4 Hz or lower. Meanwhile the didge community named this type of didgeridoo the deep instrument (even today, instruments in C 65.4 Hz or B 61.7 Hz and/or 2 metres long are wrongly considered deep too).
As for me, in September 2009 I started playing PVC pipes in A 55 Hz and within six months I had reached instruments in G 24.5 Hz, perhaps even lower, up to 7 metres long. Two years on, I decided to share my experience, also trying to answer a question many people have asked me: when can an instrument be considered a deep instrument?
Common, middle and deep
The first step is to define which parameters to use. I have identified two: the leading one is certainly the key, then there is the length, which helps to understand the potential playability. To keep things simple I always consider mixed shapes: a cylindrical first part and a slightly conical second part. Here are the three main categories I have identified:
| Category | Key | Length |
|---|---|---|
| Common | from G 97.9 Hz to B 61.7 Hz | 100–250 cm |
| Middle | from A 55 Hz to E 41.2 Hz | 260/270–380/390 cm |
| Deep | D 36.7 Hz or lower | at least 4 m |
So I consider deep only instruments in D 36.7 Hz or lower; for good playability and a pleasant sound I recommend a minimum length of 4 metres. Many might rightly object that you can get a D 36.7 Hz from an instrument just 3 metres long. You are right, but playability and sound quality will suffer.
Next, some answers to the questions I have been asked most often in recent years.
What is the lowest note of a deep instrument?
In theory, with the same shape, the longer the instrument the lower the note. But the human ear perceives sounds between about 20 and 20,000 Hz: even if you managed to play an instrument in C 16.3 Hz, you would not hear the fundamental, only the overtones that make up its timbre. And don't forget that reproducing and recording these frequencies requires very sophisticated equipment.
My advice
Don't go below A 27.5 Hz, or at most go down to G 24.5 Hz.
Is there a maximum length for a deep instrument?
In practice the only limits are the space available and the building skills. I went up to 7 metres and after a month I decided to take a step back and stop at 6. Why? Beyond 6.5 metres the sound starts to have something artificial about it (probably because you go below 20 Hz), the drones and toots end up at odd distances (the high ones too), everything is irregularly “out of phase”, and you feel like you are riding a bucking horse in slow motion.
Of course, with continued practice, I am sure instruments of any key and length can be tamed; but for me a 6-metre instrument in A 27.5 Hz or G 24.5 Hz is already very deep, and the voice flows very smoothly. It shouldn't turn into a contest over who plays the longest one 🙂 and it may just be a coincidence, but the air column of a B-flat tuba measures 5.90 metres.
For completeness, here are two videos of Dubravko Lapaine playing:
- a 10.3-metre instrument (from 2:40);
- an 8-metre instrument.
Lips, cheeks and diaphragm: what are the differences?
When playing a deep instrument, the lips and cheeks are very soft and the diaphragm is relatively low and relaxed: playing a deep requires much less physical effort than a common.
The real challenge is the middle. To get 100% out of a middle you need a good command of both deeps and commons, because in some passages you tighten your lips as on a common and then release them suddenly, almost as on a deep. The diaphragm works hardest of all: physically, middle instruments are the most demanding to play.
Which category offers the most possibilities?
The middles, but be careful: not because they are a compromise between common and deep. In volume, basic sound and resonance they are the best. The emphasis on low frequencies is exceptional without sacrificing the high ones; they have a back-pressure that allows not only complex rhythms and phrasing (possible on deeps too) but also playing pieces created on commons.
On deeps it is very hard to play pieces created on commons, and the real problem is that it often makes little sense: even when you manage, they sound like two completely different pieces (mine do, at least 🙂). Finally, on middles the voice travels almost as well as on deeps, and much better than on commons.
Is playing deep a fad?
No. Today (December 2011) in Italy you can count on the fingers of one hand the people who devote time and practice to middle and deep instruments. Apart from Dudo, very few people achieve noteworthy results with middles and deeps; I have not found a single video of Ondřej Smeykal himself playing middle or deep instruments.
Why start playing middles and deeps?
I started in search of new ways of expression, out of curiosity, partly as a challenge (I wanted to see what I could get out of them) and because I find low notes more fascinating, warm and hypnotic than high ones.
To close, I warmly recommend reading the story of Oldhar the Celestial Traveller on the Duende Didgeridoo website. Oldhar and my Siluro are two very different middles, and yet I can only confirm what Lapaine writes about playability:
In terms of playing the basic drone it means you have to be quite tense and quite relaxed at the same time. Especially as this tension gives you the upper harmonics of the drone, and relaxation gives the fullness of bass. So as we all want both, it makes us learn this up/down, male/female, hard/soft, yin/yang principle of the lips. But I would say the toots are the most unusual characteristic about playing this didgeridoo – they are not in the place where you are used to find them. Experience tells us it does not take long time to accustom, but it also does not take long time to lose it. So Oldhar asks either for a super-state of your overall didgeridoo playing or a very strong relation to it – playing it on a regular basis, starting from the basics.
Remember the premise, and I invite anyone with more knowledge, suitable equipment, willingness and time to expand and/or correct this article. Alternatively, write to me with changes, corrections, criticism… See you soon!
The notes mentioned in this article
| Note | Frequency | Category |
|---|---|---|
| G2 | 97.9 Hz | common |
| D2 | 73.4 Hz | common |
| C2 | 65.4 Hz | common |
| B1 | 61.7 Hz | common |
| A1 | 55.0 Hz | middle |
| E1 | 41.2 Hz | middle |
| D1 | 36.7 Hz | deep |
| A0 | 27.5 Hz | deep |
| G0 | 24.5 Hz | deep |
| C0 | 16.3 Hz | below the threshold of hearing |